Friday, June 19, 2009

"Everything That Rises Must Converge"

I think that O’Connor titled “Everything That Rises Must Converge” as she did because it represents the historical standpoint from which she was writing. “Everything that rises” seems to represent problems of social class and race reaching a boiling point. She demonstrates how there is a divide between race on the bus, and she furthers this divide by attributing characteristics of the neighborhood that Julian and his mother reside in. She makes it obvious that Julian abhors how his mother is conflicted in thinking that she still lives in the time that her grandfather Chestney did. His mother seems to perceive the rise of African American people as related to her own family’s fall from economic and social heights. She also thinks she knows who she is, and where her family belongs in a social hierarchy. From her perspective, the fact that the family is no longer rich means that society is out of order. “Must converge” symbolizes Julian’s mother’s discomfort with race and time converging. She feels uncomfortable riding the bus without Julian, and she displays a rather condescending pity for those of mixed race. All in all, though, this “convergence” is inevitable because of the cultural and political changes taking place in the 1960s in the South (the civil rights decade).


Julian and Hulga are similar in that they both display a kind of arrogance about them that is rooted in the fact that they have received higher educations. In both “Good Country People” and “Everything That Rises Must Converge,” this seems to be their downfall. Hulga thinks she holds a superiority over Manley only to discover that he has been deceiving her the entire time. Julian wants to teach his mother a “lesson” because he thinks that she doesn’t know herself, but this eventually leads to her death. She becomes so stricken by the rejection of the “Negress” that it can be assumed that her blood pressure jumps to fatal heights. Thus, the fact that both Hulga and Julian believe themselves to be intellectually superior turns out to be the cause of their misfortunes.

Thursday, June 18, 2009

"Good Country People"

The effect of the phrase “good country people” is that it encourages the reader to perceive “country people” as being harmless and genuine. O’Connor paints a picture of Mrs. Freeman as being part of this stereotype. She maintains her responsibilities without complaint, and she is an honest person. However, she has a flaw. Her flaw is that she needs to be in everyone’s business. This “flaw” foreshadows the event in which the reader recognizes that “good country people” is just a saying, with little meaning. Manley Pointer, who claims to be like Mrs. Freeman, is under guise to collect what he can from the wealthy. He poses as an innocent Bible seller, only to trick Joy (Hulga) into taking her prosthetic leg off so that he can add it to his collectables. He claims not even to be a Christian. The morale of he story here seems to be that people do not always fit a stereotype. They can put on a facade if it benefits them - it is out of ignorance that people choose to overlook this. 


Joy, with her Ph.D and many years of education, is even fooled. She seems to pride herself in her intelligence, but this pride is actually wrapped up in her leg. When her leg is removed, she no longer feels superior. However, the irony here is that her leg used to be a source of shame, whereas it becomes a source of reassurance. When Pointer runs off with it, she is once again stripped of the reassurance she felt about herself and her existence. Because of these events, O’Connor presents the cliched, but universal message, that one can not be too sure about anything, or anyone, in life, regardless of how they are portrayed. 

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Group Assignment

My group will be presenting on Hawthorne's "The Birthmark." We chose this story because we thought that the conflicts ran deeper, and that the characters were more round. The story essentially focuses on two main characters, who are very conflicted with themselves, and with nature. Nature has brought an "imperfection" to Georgiana's face in the form of a birthmark, in which both she and her husband are very troubled by. The story progresses from here, as Hawthorne dives deeper into the man vs. self and man vs. nature conflicts.

We will be presenting on Monday, June 22nd, and we will be using a facebook newsfeed to network the story. I am very excited about this project. I haven't been involved in many group projects during my experience with TCU, much less a project that allows members to interact with popular social networking strategies. 

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

"The Conversion of the Jews" and "Angel Levine"

I think that the adults in “Conversion of the Jews” represented a more traditional mode of handling Ozzie’s questioning of God, and how Jesus came to be. They seemed to look at it from a perspective of unquestionable acceptance without concrete explanation. Ozzie, on the other hand represents a less traditional stance. He seems to want an explanation, at least from the Rabbi. I don’t think he was out of line to ask so many questions - he is only thirteen and curious. However, I think that he could have laced his inquiries with more respect. He reminded me of a young child that constantly asks, “why?” to everything.


I think that Manischevitz demonstrated a level of curiosity that Ozzie did not. Less demanding, he was able to convey his uncertainty in a more respectable fashion - he did not lash out at Levine, and he certainly did not threaten to take his own life to get the answers he yearned for. However, here again an age gap is represented. Being much older than Ozzie, he at least remained respectable in his hesitation about Levine’s character. 


From what I know of the story of Job: he lived a fulfilled life, and both believed and feared in the Lord. However, as a test to his loyalty, the Lord allows Satan to take away from Job. Job suffers immensely, but and blames the Lord for injustice. However, in the end, his faith in, and loyalty to, God is only strengthened. He realizes that all that he possesses is due to God’s hand. This is similar to Malamud’s “Angel” in several ways. Manischevtiz was a successful tailor with a loving family, and then tragedy struck. His wife fell ill, his son died in the war, and his daughter abandoned him for a husband. Furthermore, Manishevtiz’s store was burned down, and he suffered aches and pains when he attempted to work. He constantly prays and wonders why God does not answer his prayers, but these prayers are out of selfishness. It is only until he becomes desperate enough to truly believe in the power of faith (belief in Levine, that is) that he is once again blessed.  At the end of the story, he remarks about the presence of Jews (angels), and how they are everywhere. 

Sunday, June 14, 2009

Author's Note

I knew right away that I wanted to create a film adaptation piece for “Management of Grief.” In my first draft, I had not yet come up with the idea to incorporate a love story. My focus was entirely on the comparison between western culture and traditional indian culture. To help the viewer better understand the stark contrast between the cultures, I changed Templeton’s occupation - she became a reporter to convey the clash between the perception of ruthless westerners, versus those who are accustomed to a more modest lifestyle in the East (Shaila and those in the indian community in the suburbs of NYC). After my attempt to highlight culture as a main theme and conflict, I then decided to take a new direction to create another conflict. In the short story, Shaila is very conflicted with herself as well, but the focus is more on the fact that she will not accept the death of her family (due in part because of her culture). In the film, I wanted the conflict to run deeper. I realized that some of the most engaging films in the drama genre (which is my intention for this film) have involved a love story of some sort. This was when I decided to transform Dr. Ranganathan’s character into that of an American journalist living in India. I thought that if viewers could recognize the internal conflict of Shaila in regard to her love for Dr. Ranganathan (Derek Walker, in the movie) they may be more prone to relate to Shaila’s character. While part of Shaila’s conflict resides in the fact that she loves an American man, another part of it involves the betrayal and guilt that she feels because of the emotion itself. I felt that this was a more universal conflict, and by making it a focal point, more viewers can relate (this conflict deals with suppressing feelings, so it can be related to in a number of ways, not necessarily directly after tragedy). 

What I really enjoy about my film adaptation was that I was able to maintain the perception of Shaila as a strong character, but through a different lens. She is not on medication, and she finds herself in constant struggle. I wanted viewers to have more insight into her character as a person, not just a mother, and an Indian women. Hence, I enjoy how this movie both distinguishes between cultures, but at the same time, conveys a larger message that as human beings, we are still linked to one another (we all share a broad nature that makes us distinct from other organisms, one of which being the desire, and vulnerability, for love). One thing I am worried about, though, is how I portray Dr. Ranganathan in the movie - more so my lack of representing his role as it is represented in the short story. In the literature, it is my understanding that his purpose is to provide readers with a male perspective for dealing with grief. Since the majority of the story centers on Shaila, Dr. Ranganathan’s presence helps broaden the readers’ perceptions of how different characters cope with loss. However, in the film it can still be assumed that he conveys internal conflict. He may not be coping with grief, as Shaila is, but he is also conflicted because he believes that, in loving Shaila, he should be strong enough to let her go so that she may fulfill what Vikram and the rest of her family had planned for themselves in America. So he, too, represents a character undergoing internalized conflict, but under a different circumstance (he has not lost his family).


Lastly, I am unsure how well I represented symbolism. I wanted viewers to be able to create their own interpretations in the movie. What the love story represented to me, may not necessarily be in line with others’ interpretations. However, I do believe that the movie presents a clear message that human beings, no matter what culture they are from, or what their life experiences may be, all possess a similar nature that brings them together - that being a need for love. 

Friday, June 12, 2009

"Paul's Case"

Paul feels that anything considered “commonplace” is unhealthy for him. He thinks that he was destined to live a finer life. Thus, he steals the bank notes and travels to New York City, where he stays for a little over a week before news reaches the Pittsburgh paper. It is in New York that he feels “at home.” He stays in a luxury hotel, dines at the elegant restaurant below, and dresses with style. The final cause in this situation is Paul’s death. Deciding not to take his life via revolver, he instead jumps in front of a train. The thought of leaving New York City, only to return to the modest “repulsive” life he lead on Cordelia Street, was “worse than jail.” He hated the smell of home cooking, the yellow wallpaper in his room, his father standing at the top of the stairway waiting for him, and the wet dishtowels. He thought that every aspect of his hometown was trivial, and that his purpose in life was to experience the elegance it had to offer. This motivation stems largely from his desire for music - he feels the “romance” of the melodies in Carnegie Hall. Lastly, it is not so much that Paul wants to be working for his success, but more so that he believes he is destined to at least live the life of a wealthy man. He finds happiness in expense, and spending a week indulging in the luxuries of New York City is worth it to him (so much so that he is willing to take his own life). 

Thursday, June 11, 2009

"Intervention"

The "enabler" that Jill Mccorkle refers to in "Intervention" is someone who ignores one's behavior, allowing them to continue to act in a destructive way. So it is used negatively in the story toward the character of Marilyn, who Rusty calls an enabler to her alcoholic husband. It is not what we think of out of a "social science" context (in general, we associate the word "enabler" with someone who provides help to one). In "Intervention," Marilyn turns her head whenever Sid is driving drunk, or passed out drunk. She is ashamed to have voiced her concern to her children that Sid may have a problem. In fact, at the end of the story when all of the children gather at their parents' house with the intent of having an intervention with Sid, Marilyn refuses to acknowledge her role in providing them with a reason to intervene. 

Sid was also an enabler for Marilyn when she was an alcoholic after she cheated on him. He turned his head the other way as well, cleaning up her mess, and avoiding questions. It was Marilyn who ultimately chose to get help for herself one evening after she had vomited all over the bathroom floor. This is another reason why she feels guilty for intervening with Sid. She feels that she should allow him to recognize his problem on his own time. However, it is ironic that Rusty call her an "enabler"  after she had played the opposite role in concerning Sally with Sid's problem.